Is It Time for a Change at Starting Quarterback for the Steelers?
- Kelly Anozie
- 21 hours ago
- 2 min read
At 5–4, the Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at a pivotal juncture in the season, clinging to a narrow lead in the AFC North.
Following a disappointing performance by veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers against the Los Angeles Chargers, questions are mounting about whether it's time to consider alternative options under center.
Rodgers, 41, showed clear signs of decline in Sunday’s loss. He completed just 16 of 31 passes for 161 yards, threw two interceptions, and was sacked three times. Most concerning was his quarterback rating of 4.6. His postgame remarks reflected his frustration: “I missed some throws I usually make… I got to play better than this for us to win.”
During the offseason, Aaron Rodgers was signed to a one-year deal with the expectation that he would elevate the Steelers’ offense and mentor younger talent. However, with Pittsburgh dropping three of its last four games and sliding in the AFC North standings, the team now faces a difficult decision: prioritize loyalty or pursue results. Rodgers’ mobility and decision-making have noticeably declined, and the offense has struggled to find rhythm.
So, what are the Steelers’ options at quarterback?
Mason Rudolph – A seasoned backup who knows the system and can manage games.
Will Howard – A rookie out of Ohio State, recently designated to return from injured reserve after a preseason hand injury.
Rudolph is the logical short-term replacement. While he’s not flashy, he has a strong arm and proved back in 2023 that he could elevate the Steelers’ offense in a short span. Howard, meanwhile, represents the future. If the Steelers fall out of playoff contention, giving him reps could be a strategic move to assess his long-term potential.
As things stand, if Rodgers continues to decline, head coach Mike Tomlin should seriously consider naming Rudolph the starter. And if the team’s playoff hopes fade, Howard may be the one best suited to take the reins. Ultimately, the Steelers need clarity at the quarterback position—and the time to begin that evaluation may be now.